Activity log for bug #1860640

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2020-01-23 09:13:25 lorn10 bug added bug
2020-01-23 09:13:25 lorn10 attachment added bootia32.efi(GitHub).zip https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1860640/+attachment/5322307/+files/bootia32.efi%28GitHub%29.zip
2020-01-23 09:14:41 lorn10 attachment added BOOTIA32.EFI(Fedora).zip https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/efibootmgr/+bug/1860640/+attachment/5322308/+files/BOOTIA32.EFI%28Fedora%29.zip
2020-01-23 09:15:24 lorn10 attachment added macboot(Fedora).zip https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/efibootmgr/+bug/1860640/+attachment/5322309/+files/macboot%28Fedora%29.zip
2020-01-23 09:15:49 lorn10 summary Add / Enable "32Bit UEFI Supportsupport" in Ubuntu? Add / Enable "32Bit UEFI Support" in Ubuntu?
2020-01-23 09:16:32 lorn10 description Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" an makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Kind regards, C. Leu [Wishlist] Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" an makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Kind regards C. Leu
2020-01-23 09:16:59 lorn10 tags wishlist
2020-01-23 11:56:40 lorn10 description Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" an makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Kind regards C. Leu Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" and makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Kind regards C. Leu
2020-02-20 14:30:13 Mario Limonciello efibootmgr (Ubuntu): importance Undecided Wishlist
2020-02-20 14:31:08 Mario Limonciello affects efibootmgr (Ubuntu) grub2 (Ubuntu)
2020-12-18 14:55:44 lorn10 description Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" and makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Kind regards C. Leu Hi there! I want to add here a request regarding the addition of a very nice, currently Fedora-exclusive, feature. It's called "32Bit UEFI Support" and makes it possible to boot and install a 64bit Linux onto a 32 bit (U)EFI based system which contains a 64bit CPU. Source: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/32BitUefiSupport So far I understand, this works through a special modified BOOTIA32.EFI file. That one acts as some kind of a "wrapper" which converts some (essential) EFI64 calls to EFI32 (during the boot-up). I have tested this principle with latest Fedora 31 at an early Intel iMac which contains a 64bit CPU but has a 32bit EFI. To my big surprise it works absolutely GREAT! There exist currently some ways to apply this principle also at other Linux Distros like Ubuntu and Debian. Unfortunately these are all quite complex and needs a lot of modifications. More information can be found at the following link: https://medium.com/@realzedgoat/a-sorta-beginners-guide-to-installing-ubuntu-linux-on-32-bit-uefi-machines-d39b1d1961ec I tried to modify a Kubuntu 18.04 LTS DVD ISO image but I failed. Fedora Linux uses a quite different DVD install layout (folder & file organization) which is not easy applicable at Ubuntu / Debian based Distros. In detail I tried to copy the mentioned BOOTIA32.EFI wrapper file into the /EFI/boot directory. Well, the edited / modified Kubuntu DVD image was not recognized by the 32bit EFI firmware (at an iMac). I have uploaded some of the needed files. Fedora seems to include also a special macboot.img file which is not present (in that form) in Ubuntu. Update 18.12.2020: The following link shows a step-by-step guide how an installation can be done with latest Ubuntu / Kubuntu 20.04 LTS: https://wiki.ubuntuusers.de/Howto/32-Bit_EFI/ As mentioned in my initial request the main problem lies in the missing grubia32.efi file. That one is unfortunately not included at current Ubuntu 64 bit x86-64 install medias. So it is needed to add it from another Distro like Debian 10. Note, Debian supports that "64bit CPU & 32bit EFI" install option since Version 8: https://wiki.debian.org/UEFI#Support_for_mixed-mode_systems:_64-bit_system_with_32-bit_UEFI Kind regards C. Leu
2021-01-16 16:52:44 Ikuya Awashiro bug added subscriber Ikuya Awashiro
2022-01-08 03:20:45 mirh bug added subscriber mirh
2022-01-08 03:20:54 Launchpad Janitor grub2 (Ubuntu): status New Confirmed
2022-01-10 10:33:33 Julian Andres Klode grub2 (Ubuntu): status Confirmed Opinion