| 2009-05-25 00:04:57 |
BrainwreckedTech |
bug |
|
|
added bug |
| 2009-05-25 09:30:08 |
BrainwreckedTech |
description |
== THINGS NEEDED TO REPRODUCE ==
Ubuntu 8.10 and Ubuntu 9.04 and their respective versions of Ekiga
Ekiga.net account
Diamondcard.us account
Two consumer-grade routers (my case, a Buffalo AirStation WHR-G45S and Asus WL-520G, both running DD-WRT v24-sp1 (07/27/08) std)
Set one router to connect to the Cable/DSL modem
Set the second router to treat the the first router as a WAN
Forwarding of ports 5000-5100 UDP so that the second router can receive SIP traffic and forward it to a particular internal IP address.
== WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 2.0 (default Ubuntu 8.10 version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Setup Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== WORKING SOLUTION (UNCONFIRMED) ==
(This is a past setup I cannot reproduce because the SVN has moved on)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.0 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== UNTESTED SOLUTION ==
(Currently Ekiga's SVN has no intrepid packages)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.2.4 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Set up Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
== NON-WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 9.04 and Ekiga 3.2 (default Ubuntu 9.04 version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test fails (User not available)
Set up Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Ekiga receives call through the Diamondcard.us account as expected
During received calls, sound only comes in. The person calling in cannot hear the recipient behind Ekiga. |
== THINGS NEEDED TO REPRODUCE ==
Ubuntu 8.10 and Ubuntu 9.04 and their respective versions of Ekiga
Ekiga.net account
Diamondcard.us account
Two consumer-grade routers (my case, a Buffalo AirStation WHR-G45S and Asus WL-520G, both running DD-WRT v24-sp1 (07/27/08) std)
Set one router to connect to the Cable/DSL modem
Set the second router to treat the the first router as a WAN
Forwarding of ports 5000-5100 UDP so that the second router can receive SIP traffic and forward it to a particular internal IP address.
== WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 2.0 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 8.10)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Setup Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== WORKING SOLUTION (UNCONFIRMED) ==
(This is a past setup I cannot reproduce because the SVN has moved on)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.0 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== UNTESTED SOLUTION ==
(Currently Ekiga's SVN has no intrepid packages)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.2.4 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Set up Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
== NON-WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 9.04 and Ekiga 3.2 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 9.04)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test fails (User not available)
Set up Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Ekiga receives call through the Diamondcard.us account as expected
During received calls, sound only comes in. The person calling in cannot hear the recipient behind Ekiga. |
|
| 2009-07-05 13:31:33 |
Alvin |
bug watch added |
|
http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=341518 |
|
| 2009-07-08 12:03:12 |
BrainwreckedTech |
tags |
|
ekiga |
|
| 2009-07-08 12:03:45 |
BrainwreckedTech |
tags |
ekiga |
1500 ekiga mtu pdu udp |
|
| 2009-07-08 12:23:10 |
BrainwreckedTech |
description |
== THINGS NEEDED TO REPRODUCE ==
Ubuntu 8.10 and Ubuntu 9.04 and their respective versions of Ekiga
Ekiga.net account
Diamondcard.us account
Two consumer-grade routers (my case, a Buffalo AirStation WHR-G45S and Asus WL-520G, both running DD-WRT v24-sp1 (07/27/08) std)
Set one router to connect to the Cable/DSL modem
Set the second router to treat the the first router as a WAN
Forwarding of ports 5000-5100 UDP so that the second router can receive SIP traffic and forward it to a particular internal IP address.
== WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 2.0 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 8.10)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Setup Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== WORKING SOLUTION (UNCONFIRMED) ==
(This is a past setup I cannot reproduce because the SVN has moved on)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.0 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== UNTESTED SOLUTION ==
(Currently Ekiga's SVN has no intrepid packages)
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 3.2.4 (SVN version)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Set up Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
== NON-WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 9.04 and Ekiga 3.2 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 9.04)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test fails (User not available)
Set up Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Ekiga receives call through the Diamondcard.us account as expected
During received calls, sound only comes in. The person calling in cannot hear the recipient behind Ekiga. |
== THINGS NEEDED TO REPRODUCE ==
Ubuntu 8.10 and Ubuntu 9.04 and their respective versions of Ekiga
Ekiga.net account
Diamondcard.us account
Two consumer-grade routers (my case, a Buffalo AirStation WHR-G45S and Asus WL-520G, both running DD-WRT v24-sp1 (07/27/08) std)
Set one router to connect to the Cable/DSL modem
Set the second router to treat the the first router as a WAN
Forwarding of ports 5000-5100 UDP so that the second router can receive SIP traffic and forward it to a particular internal IP address.
== WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 8.10 with Ekiga 2.0 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 8.10)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test works as exepected
Setup Ekiga with a Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Diamondcard.us echo test works as expected
== WORKING SOLUTION (UNCONFIRMED) ==
[deleted July 10 2009 -- not needed]
== UNTESTED SOLUTION ==
[deleted July 10 2009 -- not needed]
== NON-WORKING SOLUTION ==
Ubuntu 9.04 and Ekiga 3.2 (default version that ships with Ubuntu 9.04)
Set up Ekiga with an Ekiga.net account
Ekiga.net login works as expected
Ekiga.net echo test fails (User not available)
Set up Diamondcard.us account
Diamondcard.us login works as expected
Ekiga receives call through the Diamondcard.us account as expected
During received calls, sound only comes in. The person calling in cannot hear the recipient behind Ekiga.
========== UPDATE JULY 10 2009 ==========
After some discussion, the problem I was having was not with a double-NAT set up but rather an MTU setting. If you have optimized your MTU packet size for a local gigabit LAN, chances are it is higher than the Internet standard of 1500. Currently, Ekiga 3.2.0 only supports communications using UDP packets, and they cannot be fragmented into smaller packets. TCP packets can be fragmented, but TCP is currently not implemented (though high on the TODO). If you issue the command ifconfig [interface] mtu 1500 (where [interface] is something along the lines of eth0) and everything starts working, then this was your problem. If you're still having problems, try the Ekiga Echo Test. If the Ekiga Echo Test works and the other SIP server/peer does not, chances are that you and this other SIP server/peer you are connecting to cannot negotiate a codec that will fit inside this limit.
========================================= |
|
| 2009-07-09 23:22:17 |
Alvin |
summary |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 Does not work behind double-NAT |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 Default config gives oversized UDP packets |
|
| 2009-07-09 23:24:32 |
Alvin |
ekiga (Ubuntu): status |
New |
Confirmed |
|
| 2009-07-10 01:54:59 |
BrainwreckedTech |
summary |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 Default config gives oversized UDP packets |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 Obeys Local Machine MTU Settings, Tries Nothing Else |
|
| 2009-07-10 08:17:05 |
Alvin |
removed subscriber Alvin |
|
|
|
| 2009-07-10 22:06:55 |
BrainwreckedTech |
attachment added |
|
This is the full debug output when all codecs are selected. Call ends with "User Not Available." http://launchpadlibrarian.net/28896426/ekiga-debug5-allcodecs-launchpad.txt |
|
| 2009-07-10 22:08:32 |
BrainwreckedTech |
attachment added |
|
This is the full debug output when deselecting all codecs except GSM. Call connects, but no incoming sound is heard. http://launchpadlibrarian.net/28896452/ekiga-debug5-gsmonly-launchpad.txt |
|
| 2009-07-10 22:22:23 |
BrainwreckedTech |
attachment added |
|
This is the full debug output when all codecs are selected and the mtu is set to 1500. Everything works as expected. http://launchpadlibrarian.net/28896800/ekiga-debug5-mtu1500-launchpad.txt |
|
| 2009-07-10 22:30:18 |
BrainwreckedTech |
attachment added |
|
This is the full debug output when only PCMA is selected and the MTU is still 7000. IT WORKS! http://launchpadlibrarian.net/28897041/ekiga-debug5-pcmaonly-launchpad.txt |
|
| 2009-08-07 19:06:32 |
Yannick Defais |
summary |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 Obeys Local Machine MTU Settings, Tries Nothing Else |
Ubuntu 9.04 Ekiga 3.2.0 If PDU is way larger than standard MTU (1500), even if local MTU is large enough (7000), connection timeout. |
|
| 2009-08-07 19:25:20 |
Yannick Defais |
bug task added |
|
ekiga |
|
| 2009-08-07 19:26:20 |
Yannick Defais |
ekiga: status |
Unknown |
In Progress |
|
| 2009-08-07 19:26:29 |
Yannick Defais |
ekiga (Ubuntu): status |
Confirmed |
In Progress |
|
| 2009-08-08 17:33:41 |
Bug Watch Updater |
ekiga: status |
In Progress |
New |
|
| 2009-08-25 14:56:35 |
Pedro Villavicencio |
ekiga (Ubuntu): importance |
Undecided |
Low |
|
| 2010-09-16 15:42:29 |
Bug Watch Updater |
ekiga: importance |
Unknown |
High |
|
| 2015-04-10 01:28:32 |
Bug Watch Updater |
ekiga: status |
New |
Confirmed |
|
