holding a package in aptitude does not set dpkg's selection

[bgruber]

Binary package hint: aptitude

If I hold a package in aptitude, everything else (update manager, apt-get, etc) still wants to upgrade it. Finally figured out that I wanted 'dpkg --set-selections'. Marking a package to be held in aptitude should be reflected in the other package management tools, just as marking a package as automatically installed is now.

[Matt Zimmerman (mdz)]

# aptitude uses its own state information
reassign 174091 aptitude
severity 174091 normal
merge 174091 137771

severity 171248 normal
retitle 171248 corrupted cache files cause segfault
merge 165448 171248

thanks

--
 - mdz

[Daniel Burrows (dburrows)]

severity 161810 normal
merge 161810 137771
thanks

On Sat, Sep 21, 2002 at 08:53:34PM +0200, <email address hidden> was heard to say:
> Package: aptitude
> Version: 0.2.11.1-3
> Severity: wishlist
>
> I have installed several packages manualy, because I added a patch there, which
> is long outstanding on program's bugtrack, but was not applied yet. I have set
> the packages on hold using aptitude. But apt-get, dpkg nor dselect honor this
> seting. I think aptitude should set the hold flag globally, not just for it's
> internal use.
>
> -- System Information
> Debian Release: testing/unstable
> Kernel Version: Linux vagabond 2.4.19 #11 Po srp 5 12:31:27 CEST 2002 i686 unknown unknown GNU/Linux
>
> Versions of the packages aptitude depends on:
> ii libc6 2.2.5-14.3 GNU C Library: Shared libraries and Timezone
> ii libncurses5 5.2.20020112a- Shared libraries for terminal handling
> ii libsigc++0 1.0.4-3 Type-safe Signal Framework for C++ - runtime
> ii libstdc++2.10- 2.95.4-11 The GNU stdc++ library
> ii apt 0.5.4 Advanced front-end for dpkg
> ^^^ (Provides virtual package libapt-pkg-libc6.2-3-2-3.2)
>
>

--
/-------------------- Daniel Burrows <email address hidden> -------------------\
| "Oh my god! The entire map is written in GIBBERISH!" |
| "Worse, my friend. It's written in German!" -- Fluble |
\------- (if (not (understand-this)) (go-to http://www.schemers.org)) --------/

[Kai Henningsen (kai-debbugs)]

submitter 7181 !
submitter 7182 !
submitter 9932 !
submitter 9936 !
submitter 9939 !
submitter 9940 !
submitter 9942 !
submitter 9944 !
submitter 9945 !
submitter 9946 !
submitter 13976 !
submitter 17065 !
submitter 17210 !
submitter 20378 !
submitter 20379 !
submitter 20381 !
submitter 20382 !
submitter 20658 !
submitter 20895 !
submitter 20910 !
submitter 20949 !
submitter 20956 !
submitter 21665 !
submitter 21747 !
submitter 23242 !
submitter 23476 !
submitter 23692 !
submitter 23912 !
submitter 25017 !
submitter 25262 !
submitter 26805 !
submitter 27126 !
submitter 27127 !
submitter 27692 !
submitter 31208 !
submitter 31312 !
submitter 32888 !
submitter 33007 !
submitter 33008 !
submitter 33009 !
submitter 34616 !
submitter 35168 !
submitter 37337 !
submitter 38514 !
submitter 40085 !
submitter 41107 !
submitter 41839 !
submitter 42241 !
submitter 42288 !
submitter 42338 !
submitter 43657 !
submitter 43658 !
submitter 43659 !
submitter 43668 !
submitter 43900 !
submitter 44375 !
submitter 44376 !
submitter 44377 !
submitter 44379 !
submitter 44866 !
submitter 44921 !
submitter 45480 !
submitter 46931 !
submitter 47440 !
submitter 47493 !
submitter 47512 !
submitter 48518 !
submitter 48670 !
submitter 48683 !
submitter 48806 !
submitter 49453 !
submitter 49454 !
submitter 49597 !
submitter 49599 !
submitter 49613 !
submitter 49616 !
submitter 49617 !
submitter 50180 !
submitter 50200 !
submitter 50266 !
submitter 50390 !
submitter 50584 !
submitter 50665 !
submitter 50673 !
submitter 51530 !
submitter 51804 !
submitter 52218 !
submitter 52226 !
submitter 52227 !
submitter 52442 !
submitter 52614 !
submitter 52720 !
submitter 52725 !
submitter 52873 !
submitter 53140 !
submitter 53234 !
submitter 53420 !
submitter 53448 !
submitter 55032 !
submitter 57747 !
submitter 58469 !
submitter 59539 !
submitter 63691 !
submitter 64280 !
submitter 64821 !
submitter 66073 !
submitter 66080 !
submitter 68773 !
submitter 69111 !
submitter 69548 !
submitter 73659 !
submitter 73671 !
submitter 74087 !
submitter 74442 !
submitter 74722 !
submitter 74734 !
submitter 74741 !
submitter 75256 !
submitter 75662 !
submitter 75936 !
submitter 76648 !
submitter 76856 !
submitter 77349 !
submitter 77911 !
submitter 78561 !
submitter 79163 !
submitter 79164 !
submitter 80401 !
submitter 80468 !
submitter 80474 !
submitter 80900 !
submitter 82935 !
submitter 82942 !
submitter 85069 !
submitter 85586 !
submitter 88173 !
submitter 88484 !
submitter 89245 !
submitter 91796 !
submitter 91817 !
submitter 91872 !
submitter 91935 !
submitter 92130 !
submitter 92133 !
submitter 92134 !
submitter 92287 !
submitter 97551 !
submitter 97743 !
submitter 98229 !
submitter 99785 !
submitter 102005 !
submitter 103020 !
submitter 106803 !
submitter 109310 !
submitter 113021 !
submitter 113990 !
submitter 115533 !
submitter 115536 !
submitter 115539 !
submitter 119307 !
submitter 126176 !
submitter 126201 !
submitter 126254 !
submitter 126876 !
submitter 127192 !
submitter 129726 !
submitter 130798 !
submitter 131866 !
submitter 132041 !
submitter 134693 !
submitter 135252 !
submitter 139358 !
submitter 140565 !
submitter 143606 !
submitter 143607 !
submitter 143609 !
submitter 146413...

[Marc Haber (mh+debian-packages)]

Hi Daniel,

may I inquire about the status of these two bugs? The non-interface of
aptitude with apt-get makes aptitude's holds especially useless if one
uses cron-apt because cron-apt uses apt-get which ignores aptitudes
holds.

Can you please talk with the apt maintainers how this could be solved
in time for sarge?

Greetings
Marc

--
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marc Haber | "I don't trust Computers. They | Mailadresse im Header
Karlsruhe, Germany | lose things." Winona Ryder | Fon: *49 721 966 32 15
Nordisch by Nature | How to make an American Quilt | Fax: *49 721 966 31 29

[Daniel Burrows (dburrows)]

severity 277719 normal
merge 277719 137771 220794
thanks
--
/------------------- Daniel Burrows <email address hidden> ------------------\
| "It is said that someone at a party once asked |
| the famous philosopher Ly Tin Weedle, 'why |
| are you here?', and the reply took three years." |
| -- Terry Pratchett |
\---------------- The Turtle Moves! -- http://www.lspace.org ---------------/

[Daniel Burrows (dburrows)]

# Automatically generated email from bts, devscripts version 2.10.11
forcemerge 137771 453702

[bgruber (bgruber)]

Binary package hint: aptitude

If I hold a package in aptitude, everything else (update manager, apt-get, etc) still wants to upgrade it. Finally figured out that I wanted 'dpkg --set-selections'. Marking a package to be held in aptitude should be reflected in the other package management tools, just as marking a package as automatically installed is now.

[xavierzenith (xavierzenith)]

Agreed.

[=?UTF-8?Q?T=C3=A1ssia_Cam=C3=B5es_Ar?==?UTF-8?Q?a=C3=BAjo?= (debian-tassia)]

package apticron
block 431869 by 137771
thanks

It is true that apticron doesn't use aptitude, but as long as I understand the
problem, this is still an aptitude bug. The question is the way you put
packages on hold. If you use aptitude for that (# aptitude hold foo), neither
apt nor dselect will consider it because it saves that information into an
internal database (see #137771). While if you do that by the traditional way
(# echo "foo hold" | dpkg --set-selections) it is considered by apt-get, and
also by apticron.

I'll block this bug, since it cannot be fixed before having #137771 fixed.

Regards,

--
Tássia Camões Araújo

[jidanni (dan-jacobson)]

forcemerge 137771 146207
forcemerge 137771 199887
thanks
hope this is right, just trying to help

[Florian Rathgeber (florian-rathgeber)]

Confirmed on natty x64 (aptitude 0.6.3-3.2ubuntu1).

[Rolf Leggewie (r0lf)]

bug 185981 and bug 75332 look like dupes.