Activity log for bug #2023637

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2023-06-13 09:03:51 David Hedlund bug added bug
2023-06-13 09:05:35 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679437/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 09:05:52 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679438/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 09:07:24 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679439/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 09:07:33 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679440/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 09:07:43 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_3.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679441/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_ext4-screenshot_3.png
2023-06-13 09:08:06 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679442/+files/Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 09:08:17 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679443/+files/Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 09:08:25 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679444/+files/Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png
2023-06-13 09:08:36 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679445/+files/Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 09:08:44 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679446/+files/Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 09:11:23 David Hedlund description I'll update screenshots See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 22.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV
2023-06-13 09:12:31 David Hedlund description See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 22.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV
2023-06-13 09:12:45 David Hedlund summary Cannot shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu 22.04 but not in Ubuntu Server 22.04 Cannot shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu 22.04/23.10 but not in Ubuntu Server 22.04
2023-06-13 09:13:15 David Hedlund tags jammy
2023-06-13 09:13:31 David Hedlund tags jammy jammy mantic
2023-06-13 09:19:36 David Hedlund description See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV I used gparted 1.3.1 in Ubuntu 22.04 and installed and mounted Ubuntu on other disk drives that I mounted: * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV See the screenshots for details.
2023-06-13 09:25:45 David Hedlund summary Cannot shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu 22.04/23.10 but not in Ubuntu Server 22.04 Cannot shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu 22.04/23.04 but not in Ubuntu Server 22.04
2023-06-13 09:25:56 David Hedlund description I used gparted 1.3.1 in Ubuntu 22.04 and installed and mounted Ubuntu on other disk drives that I mounted: * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.10, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV See the screenshots for details. See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.04, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV
2023-06-13 09:26:37 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679453/+files/Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 09:26:47 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679454/+files/Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 09:29:33 David Hedlund description See the screenshots * Ubuntu 22.04, and Ubuntu 23.04, can not LVM2 PV * Ubuntu server 22.04 can resize LVM2 PV gparted 1.3.1 status: * Disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots
2023-06-13 09:30:25 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 status: * Disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots
2023-06-13 09:30:46 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots
2023-06-13 09:33:25 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached Disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached Disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots
2023-06-13 09:37:05 David Hedlund bug added subscriber Phillip Susi
2023-06-13 09:37:51 David Hedlund bug added subscriber Thomas Ward
2023-06-13 09:40:04 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files.
2023-06-13 09:40:43 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. The only way to circumvent this is to buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:41:10 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. The only way to circumvent this is to buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:45:41 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:46:16 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:46:38 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:47:08 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV -- see Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png, Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png See the screenshots This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:47:31 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:47:57 David Hedlund summary Cannot shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu 22.04/23.04 but not in Ubuntu Server 22.04 Can shrink LVM2 PV file system in Ubuntu Server 22.04 but not in Ubuntu 22.04/23.04
2023-06-13 09:48:29 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 09:51:25 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: Can shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 10:05:43 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 22.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 10:06:41 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 11:27:50 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     See: * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV See: * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV See:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 11:36:14 David Hedlund affects gparted (Ubuntu) ubuntu
2023-06-13 15:17:02 David Hedlund attachment removed Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679445/+files/Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-13 15:17:10 David Hedlund attachment removed Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679446/+files/Ubuntu_23.10_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-13 15:21:41 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     See: * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV See: * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV See:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachments references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachments references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-13 15:22:03 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachments references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachments references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB).
2023-06-15 10:29:34 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS) status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Trisquel 11 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 10:30:19 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Trisquel 11 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 10:57:37 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one has to buy really small SSD drives (16-32 GB). 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 11:19:09 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679915/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM%20%28disk%20image%20restored%20to%20a%20much%20larger%20disk%20than%20the%20disk%20image%20to%20demonstrate%20that%20the%20LVM%20can%20be%20enlarged%29%20-screenshot_1.png
2023-06-15 11:19:20 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679916/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM%20%28disk%20image%20restored%20to%20a%20much%20larger%20disk%20than%20the%20disk%20image%20to%20demonstrate%20that%20the%20LVM%20can%20be%20enlarged%29%20-screenshot_2.png
2023-06-15 11:19:29 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679917/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM%20%28disk%20image%20restored%20to%20a%20much%20larger%20disk%20than%20the%20disk%20image%20to%20demonstrate%20that%20the%20LVM%20can%20be%20enlarged%29%20-screenshot_3.png
2023-06-15 11:19:38 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679918/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM%20%28disk%20image%20restored%20to%20a%20much%20larger%20disk%20than%20the%20disk%20image%20to%20demonstrate%20that%20the%20LVM%20can%20be%20enlarged%29%20-screenshot_4.png
2023-06-15 11:19:46 David Hedlund attachment added Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2023637/+attachment/5679919/+files/Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM%20%28disk%20image%20restored%20to%20a%20much%20larger%20disk%20than%20the%20disk%20image%20to%20demonstrate%20that%20the%20LVM%20can%20be%20enlarged%29%20-screenshot_5.png
2023-06-15 11:23:16 David Hedlund description gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. LVM can be enlarged.[1] But not shrieked: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 11:23:38 David Hedlund description LVM can be enlarged.[1] But not shrieked: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. LVM can be enlarged in Ubuntu.[1] But not shrieked: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 11:23:57 David Hedlund description LVM can be enlarged in Ubuntu.[1] But not shrieked: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. LVM can be enlarged in Ubuntu.[1] But not shrunken: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.
2023-06-15 11:24:59 David Hedlund description LVM can be enlarged in Ubuntu.[1] But not shrunken: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted. LVM can be enlarged for attached disk drives with Ubuntu installed[1] but they can not be shrunken: gparted 1.3.1 (tested with Ubuntu 23.04 as host OS)[1] status: * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu Server 22.04 installed: CAN shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu-server_22.04-LVM-screenshot_3.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 22.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png * Attached a disk drive with Ubuntu 23.04 installed: Can not shrink LVM2 PV     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_23.04_with_LVM-screenshot_2.png This bug prevents people to make default partition installations of Ubuntu with LVM, and then shrink the file system, which is useful if you want to save disk image (.img) files. To circumvent the issue, one could * Buy small SSD drives (16-32 GB), and fill them * Or 1) perform installation on typical large SSD drives. 2) Create partition images of only the used space, to shrink the disk image size in the next step. 3) Create a disk image. 1: LVM can be enlarged:     Bug attachment references:     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_1.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_2.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_3.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_4.png     * Ubuntu_22.04_with_LVM (disk image restored to a much larger disk than the disk image to demonstrate that the LVM can be enlarged) -screenshot_5.png 2: Note that you'll not be able to mount the LVMs from the attached disk drives due to duplicated VG names, but that is not needed to demostrate this bug. However, ff you need to mount them, you can run Trisquel instead, that is using "vgtrisquel" as VG name. Or vote for "Add unique VG name to avoid activating multiple VGs with the same name from multiple disk" - https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/2023970 that I submitted.