Activity log for bug #984953

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2012-04-18 14:30:23 Volker Grabsch bug added bug
2012-04-18 14:30:23 Volker Grabsch attachment added Example disk image that triggers the bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/984953/+attachment/3089614/+files/test-2M-2.raw.bz2
2012-04-18 14:37:39 Volker Grabsch description When using "qemu-img convert" to create a VDI image, the VDI image is valid, but may contain an altered disk image. When such an image is run under VirtualBox, subtle bugs such as spontaneous segmentation faults happen because of broken system libraries. The following set of commands reproduces the bug (using the provided test disk image slice): bunzip2 < test-2M-2.raw.bz2 > test.raw qemu-img convert -O vdi test.raw test-2.vdi qemu-img convert -O raw test-2.vdi test-2.raw diff -qs test.raw test-2.raw # Output: Files test.raw and test-2.raw differ If the VDI image is created via "VBoxManage convertfromraw", everything is okay: VBoxManage convertfromraw test.raw test-3.vdi --format VDI 2>/dev/null qemu-img convert -O raw test-3.vdi test-3.raw diff -qs test.raw test-3.raw # Output: Files test.raw and test-3.raw are identical When using "qemu-img convert" to create a VDI image, the VDI image is valid, but may contain an altered disk image. When such an image is run under VirtualBox, subtle bugs such as spontaneous segmentation faults happen because of broken system libraries. The following set of commands reproduces the bug (using the provided test disk image slice): bunzip2 < test-2M-2.raw.bz2 > test.raw qemu-img convert -O vdi test.raw test-2.vdi qemu-img convert -O raw test-2.vdi test-2.raw diff -qs test.raw test-2.raw # Output: Files test.raw and test-2.raw differ If the VDI image is created via "VBoxManage convertfromraw", everything is okay: VBoxManage convertfromraw test.raw test-3.vdi --format VDI qemu-img convert -O raw test-3.vdi test-3.raw diff -qs test.raw test-3.raw # Output: Files test.raw and test-3.raw are identical
2012-04-18 17:15:45 Stefan Weil qemu: assignee Stefan Weil (ubuntu-weilnetz)
2012-04-22 19:31:39 Stefan Weil marked as duplicate 919242
2012-04-22 19:32:52 Stefan Weil qemu: status New Fix Committed