Activity log for bug #1611836

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2016-08-10 16:02:27 Richard Theis bug added bug
2016-08-10 16:04:16 Richard Theis networking-ovn: status New Confirmed
2016-08-10 16:05:25 Richard Theis description Neutron can be configured to allow overlapping IP addresses (see the allow_overlapping_ips configuration option). This is the default in DevStack. With overlapping IP addresses (as the example shows below), OVN address sets do not store duplicate addresses. As a result, deleting a port with a duplicate IP address on the same security group will result in networking-ovn removing the overlapping IP address from the security group's address set. $ openstack network create network1 $ openstack network create network2 $ openstack subnet create --subnet-range 10.1.0.0/24 --network network1 subnet1 $ openstack subnet create --subnet-range 10.1.0.0/24 --network network2 subnet2 $ openstack port create --network network1 --fixed-ip ip-address=10.1.0.10 port1 $ openstack port create --network network2 --fixed-ip ip-address=10.1.0.10 port2 $ ovn-nbctl show switch 58c1eaa8-96b3-47f5-93b1-b7c568811e3c (neutron-56a3c2a7-f70f-4614-93de-1399a81defdb) port 37cef443-4a2d-4670-8abd-05fc7d97cba0 addresses: ["fa:16:3e:b2:7e:c1 10.1.0.10"] switch acd899f1-6846-4f58-ae7c-aa72f765ea02 (neutron-95bad130-4b0c-4aa2-b11f-e1cfeb1ec62b) port 605cf49a-3d65-49b1-bb0f-7ba72ffc0b7a addresses: ["fa:16:3e:8c:0e:a1 10.1.0.10"] ... $ ovn-nbctl list address_set _uuid : 9e09ff9e-9bc7-49dc-8837-71808182a403 addresses : ["10.1.0.10"] external_ids : {"neutron:security_group_name"=default} name : "as_ip4_a420da8b_ea8b_46d4_891e_5441a87a261d" ... $ openstack port delete port2 $ ovn-nbctl list address_set _uuid : 9e09ff9e-9bc7-49dc-8837-71808182a403 addresses : [] external_ids : {"neutron:security_group_name"=default} name : "as_ip4_a420da8b_ea8b_46d4_891e_5441a87a261d" ... $ ovn-nbctl show switch 58c1eaa8-96b3-47f5-93b1-b7c568811e3c (neutron-56a3c2a7-f70f-4614-93de-1399a81defdb) port 37cef443-4a2d-4670-8abd-05fc7d97cba0 addresses: ["fa:16:3e:b2:7e:c1 10.1.0.10"] ... Neutron can be configured to allow overlapping IP addresses (see the allow_overlapping_ips configuration option). This is the default in DevStack. With overlapping IP addresses (as the example shows below), OVN address sets do not store duplicate addresses. As a result, deleting a port with a duplicate IP address on the same security group will result in networking-ovn removing the overlapping IP address from the security group's address set even though another port is using the IP address. Recreate Steps: $ openstack network create network1 $ openstack network create network2 $ openstack subnet create --subnet-range 10.1.0.0/24 --network network1 subnet1 $ openstack subnet create --subnet-range 10.1.0.0/24 --network network2 subnet2 $ openstack port create --network network1 --fixed-ip ip-address=10.1.0.10 port1 $ openstack port create --network network2 --fixed-ip ip-address=10.1.0.10 port2 $ ovn-nbctl show     switch 58c1eaa8-96b3-47f5-93b1-b7c568811e3c (neutron-56a3c2a7-f70f-4614-93de-1399a81defdb)         port 37cef443-4a2d-4670-8abd-05fc7d97cba0             addresses: ["fa:16:3e:b2:7e:c1 10.1.0.10"]     switch acd899f1-6846-4f58-ae7c-aa72f765ea02 (neutron-95bad130-4b0c-4aa2-b11f-e1cfeb1ec62b)         port 605cf49a-3d65-49b1-bb0f-7ba72ffc0b7a             addresses: ["fa:16:3e:8c:0e:a1 10.1.0.10"] ... $ ovn-nbctl list address_set _uuid : 9e09ff9e-9bc7-49dc-8837-71808182a403 addresses : ["10.1.0.10"] external_ids : {"neutron:security_group_name"=default} name : "as_ip4_a420da8b_ea8b_46d4_891e_5441a87a261d" ... $ openstack port delete port2 $ ovn-nbctl list address_set _uuid : 9e09ff9e-9bc7-49dc-8837-71808182a403 addresses : [] external_ids : {"neutron:security_group_name"=default} name : "as_ip4_a420da8b_ea8b_46d4_891e_5441a87a261d" ... $ ovn-nbctl show     switch 58c1eaa8-96b3-47f5-93b1-b7c568811e3c (neutron-56a3c2a7-f70f-4614-93de-1399a81defdb)         port 37cef443-4a2d-4670-8abd-05fc7d97cba0             addresses: ["fa:16:3e:b2:7e:c1 10.1.0.10"] ...
2016-08-10 16:06:11 Richard Theis summary Port IP address removed from address set when duplicate exist Port IP address removed from address set when duplicate exists
2016-11-08 18:55:59 Russell Bryant networking-ovn: importance Undecided Medium
2020-01-21 11:07:58 Lucas Alvares Gomes networking-ovn: status Confirmed Won't Fix