Activity log for bug #1914662

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2021-02-04 22:37:46 Uwe Klotz bug added bug
2021-02-04 22:39:12 Be mixxx: importance Undecided Medium
2021-02-04 22:39:13 Uwe Klotz description SoundSourceCoreAudio: Unmaintained due to lack of macOS contributors. Already requires an API adapter since the last refactoring. SoundSourceMediaFoundation: Unmaintained due to lack of Windows contributors and buggy (https://bugs.launchpad.net/mixxx/+bug/1899242) SoundSourceMP3: Based on abandoned libraries libid3tag and libmad. SoundSourceM4A: Based on abandoned (libmp4v2) and almost abandoned (libfaad2) libraries. Already requires an ugly workaround. SoundSourceSndfile: Is well maintained, has a simple API and is already used as a fallback. Currently the primary SoundSource for AIFF and WAV. No offset issues expected when switching to FFmpeg. SoundSourceWv: Minor maintenance burden, but otherwise does not hurt. The API is simple enough to keep it. SoundSourceFLAC/SoundSourceOggVorbis/SoundSourceOpus: Cannot be replaced by FFmpeg!! SoundSourceCoreAudio: Unmaintained due to lack of macOS contributors. Already requires an internal API adapter since the last refactoring. SoundSourceMediaFoundation: Unmaintained due to lack of Windows contributors and buggy (https://bugs.launchpad.net/mixxx/+bug/1899242) SoundSourceMP3: Based on abandoned libraries libid3tag and libmad. SoundSourceM4A: Based on abandoned (libmp4v2) and almost abandoned (libfaad2) libraries. Already requires an ugly workaround. SoundSourceSndfile: Is well maintained, has a simple API and is already used as a fallback. Currently the primary SoundSource for AIFF and WAV. No offset issues expected when switching to FFmpeg. SoundSourceWv: Minor maintenance burden, but otherwise does not hurt. The API is simple enough to keep it. SoundSourceFLAC/SoundSourceOggVorbis/SoundSourceOpus: Cannot be replaced by FFmpeg!!
2021-02-04 23:11:09 Uwe Klotz bug watch added https://trac.ffmpeg.org/ticket/3825
2021-02-05 01:03:24 Uwe Klotz summary Prefer FFmpeg for all formats except FLAC/OGG/OPUS Prefer FFmpeg for all formats except FLAC/OGG
2021-02-05 01:05:01 Uwe Klotz description SoundSourceCoreAudio: Unmaintained due to lack of macOS contributors. Already requires an internal API adapter since the last refactoring. SoundSourceMediaFoundation: Unmaintained due to lack of Windows contributors and buggy (https://bugs.launchpad.net/mixxx/+bug/1899242) SoundSourceMP3: Based on abandoned libraries libid3tag and libmad. SoundSourceM4A: Based on abandoned (libmp4v2) and almost abandoned (libfaad2) libraries. Already requires an ugly workaround. SoundSourceSndfile: Is well maintained, has a simple API and is already used as a fallback. Currently the primary SoundSource for AIFF and WAV. No offset issues expected when switching to FFmpeg. SoundSourceWv: Minor maintenance burden, but otherwise does not hurt. The API is simple enough to keep it. SoundSourceFLAC/SoundSourceOggVorbis/SoundSourceOpus: Cannot be replaced by FFmpeg!! SoundSourceCoreAudio: Unmaintained due to lack of macOS contributors. Already requires an internal API adapter since the last refactoring. SoundSourceMediaFoundation: Unmaintained due to lack of Windows contributors and buggy (https://bugs.launchpad.net/mixxx/+bug/1899242) SoundSourceMP3: Based on abandoned libraries libid3tag and libmad. SoundSourceM4A: Based on abandoned (libmp4v2) and almost abandoned (libfaad2) libraries. Already requires an ugly workaround. SoundSourceSndfile: Is well maintained, has a simple API and is already used as a fallback. Currently the primary SoundSource for AIFF and WAV. No offset issues expected when switching to FFmpeg. SoundSourceWv: Minor maintenance burden, but otherwise does not hurt. The API is simple enough to keep it. SoundSourceOpus: Obsolete. Contains some special metadata code that is unlikely to be used. Vorbis Comment tags are the most common. SoundSourceFLAC/SoundSourceOggVorbis: Cannot be replaced by FFmpeg!!
2021-02-09 07:18:39 Be bug watch added https://github.com/libsndfile/libsndfile/issues/643
2022-10-08 21:34:08 Swiftb0y bug watch added https://github.com/mixxxdj/mixxx/issues/10313
2022-10-08 21:34:09 Swiftb0y lock status Unlocked Comment-only