Crossfader orientation isn't saved/restored

Bug #1896832 reported by Milkii Brewster on 2020-09-23
6
This bug affects 1 person
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
Mixxx
Wishlist
Unassigned

Bug Description

If I set all channels to ignore the crossfader, then quit and restart, the options I had set have reset.

Changed in mixxx:
status: New → Confirmed
importance: Undecided → Wishlist
tags: added: easy usability
ronso0 (ronso0) wrote :

IIRC the this was supposed to avoids situations after start that are kinda hard to debug. If the orientation switches have been changed unnoticed previously, or 'in the heat of the night'.
Now (2.3) all skins (except Shade) show the crossafder switches both in 2- and 4-deck mode. Only in Tango skin they are in an unusual position, not the mixer, which is also far from the mixer.

There are at least two use cases that are affected by crossfader/orientation persistence. I assume they affect the 4-decks mode only, so we can ignore Shade skin here.

1. multiple DJs share a computer during a set and want to switch between regular crossfader usage and 'all channels centered, crossfader ignored' without the need to flip all decks switches and show/hide the crossfader via Skin Settings.

 For that we could add an option to Preferences > Crossfader called
 "Ignore crossfader", plus a CO that can be mapped in skins and on
 controllers.
 Toggle "Ignore crossfader" ON does
 * (center the crossfader, store position??)
 * store orientation of all decks
 * put all decks into their default position
 * hide the crossfader in skins
 * ignore crossfader input from controllers
 Toggle OFF does
 * restore orientation of all decks
 * (restore crossfader position??)
 * show the crossfader in skins

2. Save & restore the custom channel orientation across restarts
Example: outer decks 3/4 are left/right, decks 1+2 are always centered.
 It's tempting to add a respective option into the Decks preferences page
 (default off). But actually, since it's tightly coupled to the crossfader
 and the deck page is crammed already, it should better be in the
 Crossfader page.

Be (be.ing) wrote :

I am leaning towards simply making the crossfader orientation switches persistent in all cases. This is how every 4 deck mixer and controller with crossfader assignment switches works. I think if a user wants to change these, they probably want that change to persist.

To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  Edit
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers