From Munge - Adjustment Options

Bug #1318283 reported by Dave Nathanson
6
This bug affects 1 person
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
GNU Mailman
New
Undecided
Unassigned

Bug Description

FEATURE REQUEST:
A setting to configure the new "From" line. Instead of
FROM: Author_Name via ListName <email address hidden>

I want to request that MailMan let the list admin config the text after the author's name in the FROM line. I would use this setting to say:
FROM: Author_Name via Club Name <email address hidden>
* substituted test string "Club Name" for "List Name"
* substituted explicit reply_to_address instead of list address.

More details:

My email lists are served from a sub-domain that I don't use for anything except lists. lists.example.com That is a given, not my option.

I have things figured out as well as can be for my situation.
The settings we are going to use are:
  reply_goes_to_list = Explicit address
  reply_to_address = <email address hidden> (as opposed to <email address hidden> )
  from_is_list = Mung From
  first_strip_reply_to = Yes

The only difference is from_is_list = Mung From. The other settings are the same as before DEMARC.

Differences before & After DEMARC
BEFORE:
FROM: Author_Name <email address hidden>
TO: ListName <email address hidden>
REPLY-TO: ListName <email address hidden>

We liked it like that. Everything was fine.

AFTER DEMARC, using the best settings for us that we can (Mailman 2.1.17) :

FROM: Author_Name via ListName <email address hidden>
TO: ListName <email address hidden>
REPLY-TO: ListName <email address hidden>

This is *pretty good* except that
* I don't like the "via list name" in the from header, even though I understand that is the new reality.
* I don't like the lack of an author email address.

I also tried:
first_strip_reply_to = No
But that means a normal reply will go to both the list & the author. So the author will get 2 copies, and I don't feel that is desirable, even though it seems to be the only way to include the author's email address.

FEATURE REQUEST:
A setting to control the new "From" line. Instead of FROM: Author_Name via ListName <email address hidden>
I want to request that it offer the option to let the list admin config what goes there after the author's name. I would use this setting to say:
FROM: Author_Name via Club Name <email address hidden>
 substituted "Club Name" for "List Name", and used
 explicit reply_to_address instead of list address.

Thanks,
Dave Nathanson
Mac Medix

Tags: munge
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.