Activity log for bug #653474

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2010-10-02 08:34:04 YannUbuntu bug added bug
2010-10-02 08:43:38 YannUbuntu description Binary package hint: grub2 Many beginners try Ubuntu in dual-boot with another OS. Some of them want to remove (uninstall) Ubuntu from their computer, whatever the reason (don't like Ubuntu, or want to install it on another PC, or because Windows won't start after Ubuntu's installation..) Currently they can't do it cleanly, whatever the way they choose, they will get one of the following problems : - if they had installed Ubuntu via Wubi, they will be unhappy because Windows' bootloader will still be visible - if they installed Ubuntu on a separate partition and then format Ubuntu's partition, they won't be able to access Windows any more ( GRUB won't work any more, as it needs files that are on Ubuntu's /boot folder). - if Windows was broken by Ubuntu's installation (we see this problem several times per month on ubuntu-fr forum), they currently can't easily restaure the initial situation. Generally those users will have to re-install Windows and will discourage other people to try Ubuntu. This bug won't happen if we add a simple way to remove Ubuntu in a clean way. For example : 1) Ubuntu's installation shall save the MBR and other appropriate bytes before the installer (GRUB, or other if Wubi) writes on them 2) The live-CD (or other appropriate place) shall propose a way to remove Ubuntu by restauring the bytes saved in 1). - OR from the Administration menu - OR somewhere more adequate Binary package hint: grub2 Many beginners try Ubuntu in dual-boot with another OS. Some of them want to remove (uninstall) Ubuntu from their computer, whatever the reason (don't like Ubuntu, or want to install it on another PC, or because Windows won't start after Ubuntu's installation..) Currently they can't do it cleanly, whatever the way they choose, they will get one of the following problems : - if they had installed Ubuntu via Wubi, they will be unhappy because Windows' bootloader will still be visible - if they installed Ubuntu on a separate partition and then format Ubuntu's partition, they won't be able to access Windows any more ( GRUB won't work any more, as it needs files that are on Ubuntu's /boot folder). - if Windows was broken by Ubuntu's installation (we see this problem several times per month on ubuntu-fr forum), they currently can't easily restaure the initial situation. Generally those users will have to re-install Windows and will discourage other people to try Ubuntu. This bug won't happen if we add a simple way to remove Ubuntu in a clean way. For example : 1) Ubuntu's installation shall save the MBR and other appropriate bytes before the installer (GRUB, or other if Wubi) writes on them 2) The live-CD (or other appropriate place) shall propose a way to remove Ubuntu by restauring the bytes saved in 1). Hope this helps making Ubuntu better.
2010-10-02 08:53:38 Nicolas Delvaux bug added subscriber Nicolas Delvaux
2010-10-05 10:54:50 YannUbuntu bug task added ubiquity
2010-10-05 11:19:50 Colin Watson ubiquity: status New Invalid
2010-10-05 11:56:20 YannUbuntu bug task added ayatana-ubuntu
2011-07-05 00:17:08 erick13_dg bug task added grub
2011-08-05 10:52:07 Launchpad Janitor grub2 (Ubuntu): status New Confirmed
2012-10-07 22:51:02 JohnWashington bug added subscriber JohnWashington
2013-01-24 18:16:19 Nikhs bug added subscriber Nikhs
2020-03-05 12:44:48 Marcus Tomlinson grub2 (Ubuntu): status Confirmed Incomplete
2020-05-06 12:12:12 Marcus Tomlinson grub2 (Ubuntu): status Incomplete Invalid