Activity log for bug #744956

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2011-03-29 13:31:26 ceg bug added bug
2011-03-29 13:40:45 ceg description It may be a desired option that deja-dup checks the UUID before starting a backup *automatically*. Howerver, it should just give a warning when the mountpoint is there but the UUID does not match, and allow to proceed anyway (manually accepting). The backup files could just have been moved to a larger disk, or one wants to alternate between disks, or backup to additional disks, mounted at the same mountpoint. Nowadays, the mountpoint is often determined by a filesystem label. If the user has explicitly given the same label (e.g. backup-disk) to another disk with a different UUID, deja-dup should not need to stop, warn and wait for confirmation. Just start the backup in this case. (With a fix for duplicity's Bug #743820, duplicity will not break on url changes (different mountpoint, hda/sda etc.) anymore. So, the restriction to a fixed url/mountpoit will also be gone in duplicity.) It may be a desired option that deja-dup checks the UUID before starting a backup *automatically*. However, it should just give a warning when the mountpoint is there but the UUID does not match, and allow to proceed anyway (manually accepting). The backup files could just have been moved to a larger disk, or one wants to alternate between disks, or backup to additional disks, mounted at the same mountpoint. Nowadays, the mountpoint is often determined by a filesystem label. If the user has explicitly given the same label (e.g. backup-disk) to another disk with a different UUID, deja-dup should not need to stop, warn and wait for confirmation. Just start the backup in this case. (With a fix for duplicity's Bug #743820, duplicity will not break on url changes anymore (different mountpoint, hda/sda etc.). So, the restriction to a fixed url/mountpoit will also be gone in duplicity. Deja-dup should just rely on duplicity to check for the correct backup ID and integrity.)
2011-05-15 20:49:31 Michael Terry summary allow a filsystem UUID change (after warning), proceed if non-empty fs label matches Merely warn on filesystem UUID change
2011-05-15 20:49:46 Michael Terry deja-dup: importance Undecided Wishlist
2011-05-15 20:49:46 Michael Terry deja-dup: status New Confirmed
2013-05-29 17:54:10 dg1727 bug added subscriber dg1727