Activity log for bug #1082001

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2012-11-22 12:26:29 MC Return bug added bug
2012-11-22 12:32:22 MC Return summary Grid/Expo: Grid resized windows via keyboard shortcuts confuse Expo and jump around from workspace to workspace Grid/Expo: Via keyboard-shortcut resized Grid windows confuse Expo and follow the user from workspace to workspace
2012-11-29 09:55:41 Omer Akram compiz: status New Confirmed
2012-12-03 11:27:17 MC Return attachment added Video was recorded using a Raring VM, has some gfx artifacts, but shows the bug clearly https://bugs.launchpad.net/compiz/+bug/1082001/+attachment/3450431/+files/Grid-keyboard-gridded-windows-jump-workspaces.webm
2013-01-26 06:57:06 Sami Jaktholm bug task added compiz (Ubuntu)
2013-01-26 06:57:13 Sami Jaktholm compiz (Ubuntu): status New Confirmed
2013-01-28 14:48:30 WhyNotHugo bug task added archlinux
2013-02-01 20:53:10 MC Return description [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. Note 3: You have to resize the windows via keyboard-grid to trigger this bug, mouse-resized *gridded* windows seem to be unaffected. [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) into a corner. Alternatively you can drag the window to a corner to grid-resize it. 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. Note 3: Just corner-gridded windows seem to be affected.
2013-02-01 20:53:36 MC Return summary Grid/Expo: Via keyboard-shortcut resized Grid windows confuse Expo and follow the user from workspace to workspace Grid/Expo: Corner-resized Grid windows confuse Expo and follow the user from workspace to workspace
2013-02-04 15:36:50 Esokrates description [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) into a corner. Alternatively you can drag the window to a corner to grid-resize it. 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. Note 3: Just corner-gridded windows seem to be affected. [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) into a corner.    Alternatively you can drag the window to a corner to grid-resize it. 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. SUMMARY: When a window gets positioned in a corner or the top/bottom half and you switch workspace using ẃorkspace switcher the window gets positioned on every workspace you switch to on exactly the same position. Same is true for dragging one window on the same workspace as the grid positioned window (corners or top/bottom half) to another workspace: the grid placed window follows to the workspace the other window is dragged to. This behavior is not true for windows that have grid positions when launched! The following video demonstrates the bug: http://ubuntuone.com/2s8kNGM6Qcp3WFfjOwe6XX
2013-02-04 15:41:35 Esokrates tags 0.9.9.2 compiz
2013-02-05 10:56:27 Esokrates tags 0.9.9.2 compiz 0.9.9.2 compiz raring
2013-02-06 14:52:07 Esokrates description [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) into a corner.    Alternatively you can drag the window to a corner to grid-resize it. 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. SUMMARY: When a window gets positioned in a corner or the top/bottom half and you switch workspace using ẃorkspace switcher the window gets positioned on every workspace you switch to on exactly the same position. Same is true for dragging one window on the same workspace as the grid positioned window (corners or top/bottom half) to another workspace: the grid placed window follows to the workspace the other window is dragged to. This behavior is not true for windows that have grid positions when launched! The following video demonstrates the bug: http://ubuntuone.com/2s8kNGM6Qcp3WFfjOwe6XX [Test Case] 1. Open a window 2. Hit "Ctrl+Alt+Numpad3" to resize it via Grid (for example Firefox) into a corner.    Alternatively you can drag the window to a corner to grid-resize it. 3. Open any other window (for example a terminal) 4. Trigger Expo (via Launcher's Workspace Switcher icon or by hitting "Super+S" for example) 5. Now drag the "non-gridded" second window (terminal in our case here) to another workspace/viewport What you would expect to happen: The terminal window should now be on the new viewport. The other window should not change position. What actually happens: No matter on which workspace the terminal window is dragged to, the *gridded* window follows. Wait, it gets even better: If you try to switch the workspace without dragging a window, the *gridded* window will follow you, whereever you go. If you resize multiple windows via Grid all will follow you from workspace to workspace. Note 1: I have tested this in a virtual machine with a vanilla default up-to-date installation of Raring also, to make sure non-default settings are not causing this problem. Note 2: This bug makes using Grid in combination with Expo (which are both enabled by default on Ubuntu) completely unusable and should have high priority. SUMMARY: When a window gets positioned in a corner or the top/bottom half and you switch workspace using ẃorkspace switcher (expo) the window gets positioned on every workspace you switch to on exactly the same position. Same is true for dragging one window on the same workspace as the grid positioned window (corners or top/bottom half) to another workspace: the grid placed window follows to the workspace the other window is dragged to. This behavior is not true for windows that have grid positions when launched! The following video demonstrates the bug: http://ubuntuone.com/2s8kNGM6Qcp3WFfjOwe6XX
2013-04-02 18:36:53 MC Return compiz: assignee MC Return (mc-return)
2013-04-02 18:38:46 MC Return summary Grid/Expo: Corner-resized Grid windows confuse Expo and follow the user from workspace to workspace Grid/Expo: Corner-, top-, bottom- and center-resized Grid windows confuse Expo and follow the user from workspace to workspace
2013-04-02 18:41:46 MC Return branch linked lp:~mc-return/compiz/compiz.merge-fix1082001-gridded-windows-jump-workspaces
2013-04-02 18:41:53 MC Return compiz: status Confirmed In Progress
2013-04-03 04:57:12 Daniel van Vugt compiz: milestone 0.9.10.0
2013-04-09 14:50:15 PS Jenkins bot compiz: status In Progress Fix Committed
2013-06-15 23:12:14 MC Return compiz: importance Undecided Critical
2013-06-15 23:12:39 MC Return compiz: importance Critical High
2013-06-15 23:30:02 WhyNotHugo bug task deleted archlinux
2013-07-23 22:06:40 Stephen M. Webb compiz: status Fix Committed Fix Released
2013-08-22 09:34:16 Launchpad Janitor compiz (Ubuntu): status Confirmed Fix Released
2013-08-22 09:34:16 Launchpad Janitor bug watch added https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=61182
2013-08-22 09:34:16 Launchpad Janitor bug watch added https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=561885
2013-08-22 09:41:51 Launchpad Janitor branch linked lp:ubuntu/saucy-proposed/compiz