Activity log for bug #253448

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2008-07-30 21:30:39 Mathias Gug bug added bug
2008-07-30 21:30:59 Mathias Gug description combine-thread is used to remove a thread from the stack when its code has been merged in one of the down-threads. However, there are use cases where the code in the thread is no longer relevant and should be completely removed. For example, ubuntu made a patch to a package. Debian fixed the bug using a different patch, thus the ubuntu patch should be completely removed from the loom (using combine-thread in this case will keep the code around in the threads above the combined threads). combine-thread is used to remove a thread from the stack when its code has been merged in one of the down-threads. However, there are use cases where the code in the thread is no longer relevant and should be completely removed. For example, ubuntu made a patch to a package. Debian fixed the bug using a different patch, thus the ubuntu patch should be completely removed from the loom (using combine-thread in this case will keep the code around in the threads above the combined thread).
2008-07-30 21:55:49 James Westby bzr-loom: status New Confirmed
2008-07-30 21:55:49 James Westby bzr-loom: importance Undecided Wishlist
2008-07-30 23:52:18 Robert Collins description combine-thread is used to remove a thread from the stack when its code has been merged in one of the down-threads. However, there are use cases where the code in the thread is no longer relevant and should be completely removed. For example, ubuntu made a patch to a package. Debian fixed the bug using a different patch, thus the ubuntu patch should be completely removed from the loom (using combine-thread in this case will keep the code around in the threads above the combined thread). Being able to say 'I do not want a thread in my branch' would be useful. combine-thread acknowledges a merge of a thread to upstream, perhaps 'eject-thread' would be a good name for something that: reverse-merges out a thread to the one above removes the lower thread from the loom (possibly) commits the merge if there were not conflicts
2008-07-30 23:52:18 Robert Collins title add a command to delete a thread an eject-thread command would be good