xquery 1.1 conformance: failing schema import tests

[Sorin Marian Nasoi]

1588:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-1
1589:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-2
1590:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-3
1629:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/SeqExprCastSI/notation-cast-3

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

1698:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-idref-30
1699:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-idref-31
1701:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-1
1702:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-2
1703:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-3
1704:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-4
1705:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-5
1729:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-10
1730:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-11
1731:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-12
1732:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-13
1733:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-14
1734:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-15
1735:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-16
1736:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-17
1737:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-18
1738:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-19
1739:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-20
1740:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-21
1741:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-22
1742:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-1
1743:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-2
1744:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-3
1745:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-4
1746:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-5
1747:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-6
1748:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-7
1749:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-8
1750:test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/NotationEQSI/Comp-notation-9

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-2

is the only tests that fails in this category: the other tests were failing because
- xs:NOTATION is not implemented in the store
- fn:id and fn:ideref and DTD's are not implemented

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

In r8707 these are the 9 tests that fail:

test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-2 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-idref-30 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-idref-31 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-1 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-2 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-3 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-4 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/MiscFunctions/fn-element-with-id-5 (Failed)
test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/SchemaImportProlog/modules-schema-context (Failed)

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

only

modules-schema-context

is failing from this category in Zorba r9010

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-2 is failing as well

[Cezar Andrei (cezar-andrei)]

Only test/rbkt/w3c_testsuite/XQuery/SchemaImport/PathExprSI/step-expr-si-2 was still failing.
Rev 9402 should fix that too.

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

Checked in r9402 and step-expr-si-2 passes.

Checked the other 2 tests as well and they also pass.

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

modules-schema-context.xq is still failing in r9448, see the reports from
http://db.tt/NoUPKfB

[Cezar Andrei (cezar-andrei)]

From Markos: This test, modules-schema-context.xq, used to pass, but after my type-related changes it doesn't pass, and according to the current XQuery specs it shouldn't pass.

The problem is really with the spec and it is described here: http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=10291

[Cezar Andrei (cezar-andrei)]

Markos, can you please follow up with w3c to remove the test or change the spec.

[Markos Zaharioudakis (markos-za)]

Which test are you talking about? The test XQuery/SchemaImport/SchemaImportProlog/modules-schema-context.xq is failing still, but the failure is not related to w3c bug #10291.

If you are talking about XQuery/SchemaImport/SchemaImportProlog/modules-schema-context.xq, this is indeed related to w3c bug #10291, but there is no follow-up I can do. They have accepted there is a problem with the spec, but they don't want to remove the test or change its expected result. They have marked the bug as RESOLVED WONTFIX.

[Cezar Andrei (cezar-andrei)]

Markos will reopen w3c bug to say we're not happy with the current resolution.

[Cezar Andrei (cezar-andrei)]

Assigned to Markos to follow with W3C.

[Sorin Marian Nasoi (sorin.marian.nasoi)]

Marked with Resolution = None at Dana's request.