[PS] Accounting - Generic Chart of Accounts - Wrong demo data

[gde (OpenERP)]

On a DB with demo data and the accounting module installed with the Generic Chart of Accounts

In the Fiscal Position in the configuration, we have two different examples:
- Normal Taxes
- Tax Exempt

In both example, we replace one 'sale' tax by a 'purchase' tax without any modification of the percentage.

Expected behavior:

- For Tax Exempt: having two lines in this fiscal position. One for the sale taxes and one for the purchase taxes with the following characteristics:
15% national sale tax replaced by 0% sale tax (stay in the same tax category)
15% national purchase tax replace by 0% purchase tax (still in the same category)

- For Normal Tax: this one is not very useful. Maybe choose another example like Export to the UK
15% national sale tax replaced by 20% UK sale tax (stay in the same tax category)
15% national purchase tax replace by 20% UK purchase tax (still in the same category)

It makes no sense to replace a sale tax by a purchase one and the aim of the demo data is to understand how a module/feature works.

[Ashvin Rathod (OpenERP) (ara-tinyerp)]

Hello gde,

Its fixed in lp:~openerp-dev/openobject-addons/trunk-bug-785110-ara branch.

Revision ID: <email address hidden>
Revision No: 4728

Thanks,
ara

[gde (OpenERP) (gde-openerp)]

Hello Ashvin,

Thanks for the review.

The fix is ok for Tax exempt but the fiscal position called 'Normal Taxes' is incorrect. In this position, we do not have to replace a 15% tax by a 0% tax.

Two choices:
- Remove this example, we do not have to replace a tax by another if we want to follow a 'classic' scenario
- Create another example to illustrate the behavior of replacing a tax by another. Example: different taxes must be applier if we sell good inside the EU or outside the EU. Maybe it could be a example.

[Mustufa Rangwala (Open ERP) (mra-tinyerp)]

I think gde(OpenERP) is correct we should not replace 15% tax by a 0% tax for "Normal tax" position.
But we can replace say 5% tax with 15% tax in the example.

@gde: correct me if i am wrong.
You can refer: http://www.openerp.com/forum/topic13402.html

Thanks for your suggestion.
mra

[gde (OpenERP) (gde-openerp)]

@Mustufa Rangwala: you are right :-)