qcommit: commit to sftp/bzr+ssh location asks password in the console

[Alexander Belchenko]

According to Maxim Tyurin report qcommit over sftp/bzr+ssh transport asked for password in the console instead of GUI dialog.

We should always force our SubprocessUI implementation for qsubprocess based dialogs. This bug seems strange.

[Alexander Belchenko (bialix)]

Maxim, can you tell version of qbzr and configuartion of your working branches: does this bug occurs with bound branches or lightweight checkouts?

[Maksym Tiurin (mrkooll)]

I have QBzr 0.14 (Bazaar 1.18) and working with bound branches like this:

 > cat .bzr/branch/branch.conf
bound_location = bzr+ssh://krt.bzr/srv/bzr/projects/Nephila/devel/
bound = True

[Gary van der Merwe (garyvdm)]

It is maybe the ssh client, and not bzr that is asking for a password. I'm not to sure how to check for this though. Please will you paste the console output to this bug. That might give us and indication.

[Maksym Tiurin (mrkooll)]

> bzr qcommit -v
<email address hidden>'s password:
Committing to: bzr+ssh://krt.bzr/srv/bzr/configs/Nephila/marla.pibhe.com/
added etc
....

Необходим пароль для доступа к секретному ключу пользователя: "Maxim Tyurin <email address hidden>"
1024-бит DSA ключ, ID 4A101D3B, создан 2002-05-27

Committed revision 44.

[Lukáš Lalinský (luks)]

Is this Windows or Linux? It's not easily possible to fix this for OpenSSH. You would have to convince the process it doesn't have an associated terminal (which I wasn't able to figure out how) and then make it launch a separate executable.

[Alexander Belchenko (bialix)]

Gary van der Merwe пишет:
> It is maybe the ssh client, and not bzr that is asking for a password.
> I'm not to sure how to check for this though. Please will you paste the
> console output to this bug. That might give us and indication.
>

I think it's OpenSSH thing.

Maxim, can you try with env variable BZR_SSH set to "paramiko" and say if there is any change in the
bzr behavior?

[Maksym Tiurin (mrkooll)]

I has changed branch path to hostname (instead of openssh alias) and set BZR_SSH=paramiko

After these changes qcommit asks the password.