Doesn't cover all Gtk stock icons

[Sebastian Dröge]

Hi,
currently tango-icon-theme doesn't cover all Gtk stock icons. IMHO it should cover them all as they are used by many applications and without having them themed some programs look rather weird.

Currently missing are at least:
GTK_STOCK_SORT_ASCENDING
GTK_STOCK_EXECUTE
GTK_STOCK_ABOUT

but most probably many more

[Michael Monreal (mimox)]

I took the time and went through the stock icon collection. Here's a list of the missing ones, I really hope we will have a complete collection for dapper:

gtk-about / required by *every* gtk application /
gtk-cdrom icon exists in tango (devices/media-cdrom) - only link is missing
gtk-connect
gtk-convert
gtk-directory icon exists in tango (places/folder) - only link is missing
gtk-disconnect
gtk-edit
gtk-execute / requred by Tomboy /
gtk-file something like mimetype/text-x-generic without the lines; easy to do
gtk-floppy icon exists in tango (devices/media-floppy) - only link is missing
gtk-font icon exists in tango (apps/preferences-desktop-font) - only link is missing
gtk-fullscreen icon exists in tango (actions/view-fullscreen) - only link is missing
gtk-harddisk / requred by gnome-system-tools /
gtk-help icon exists in tango (apps/help-browser) - only link is missing
gtk-indent-ltr icon exists in tango (actions/format-indent-more) - only link is missing
gtk-indent-rtl icon exists in tango (actions/format-indent-less) - only link is missing
gtk-index / required by Synaptic /
gtk-info
gtk-leave-fullscreen
gtk-network icon exists in tango (places/network-workgroup) - only link is missing
gtk-quit icon exists in tango (actions/system-log-out) - only link is missing
gtk-revert-to-saved-ltr
gtk-revert-to-saved-rtl
gtk-select-all icon exists in tango (actions/edit-select-all) - only link is missing
gtk-select-font
gtk-sort-ascending / requred by Tomboy /
gtk-sort-descending
gtk-spell-check tangofied version exists:
 http://ramnet.se/~nisse/diverse/temp/tango/16x16/check-spelling.png
 http://ramnet.se/~nisse/diverse/temp/tango/22x22/check-spelling.png
 http://ramnet.se/~nisse/diverse/temp/tango/check-spelling.svg
gtk-undo-rtl mirror edit undo; easy to do
gtk-zoom-100 tangofied version exists in g-i-t HEAD
gtk-zoom-fit tangofied version exists in g-i-t HEAD
gtk-zoom-in tangofied version exists in g-i-t HEAD
gtk-zoom-out tangofied version exists in g-i-t HEAD

gtk-apply.png icon exists and is discussed to go into tangerine
gtk-cancel.png icon exists and is discussed to go into tangerine
gtk-close.png tangofied version exists in g-i-t HEAD
gtk-no.png
gtk-ok.png
gtk-yes.png

gtk-dnd-multiple
gtk-dnd

gtk-dialog-authentication // required by gksu dialog //
 tangofied icon exists, was removed because not in spec:
 http://webcvs.freedesktop.org/tango/tango-icon-theme/16x16/status/locked.png
 http://webcvs.freedesktop.org/tango/tango-icon-theme/22x22/status/locked.png
 http://webcvs.freedesktop.org/tango/tango-icon-theme/scalable/status/locked.svg
gtk-dialog-question

BTW, "missing links" should be "fixed" in the icon-naming-utils package, the rest should be re-targetet tangerine-icon-theme: let's get those icons into tangerine for dapper and then try to push them into tango.

[Michael Monreal (mimox)]

let's get those icons into tangerine for dapper and then try to push them into tango

[Sebastian Dröge (slomo)]

but it also affects tango-icon-theme so let's have this assigned to both ;)

Thanks for your effort of looking through all stock icons :)

[Tollef Fog Heen (tfheen)]

Confirmed.

[Lapo Calamandrei (calamandrei)]

The next version should cover all the gtk stock, missing icons where included from the tango marathon Andreas promoted

[Bruce Cowan (bruce89-deactivatedaccount)]

In tangerine-icon-theme 0.18-0ubuntu1, gtk-dnd-multiple is only available in the 32x32 size, causing Gaim's "View Log" menu item to be a lot bigger than the others.

I thought it would be better to report this on this bug as opposed to filing a new one.

[Lapo Calamandrei (calamandrei)]

Bruce, that's an icon abuse, the stock icons which are inluded in tangerine icon themes, are the ones provided by gtk+, so I think the problem is not related to the theme itselft.

[Lapo Calamandrei (calamandrei)]

It's out of the scope of tango icon theme to cover all gtk+ stock

[VF (vfiend)]

Excuse me? Then why have new tango icons been made for every gtk stock icon, and why did you just say "The next version should cover all the gtk stock"?

[Jeff Fortin Tam (kiddo)]

My thoughts exactly.

"Tango not supposed to have those icons" because tango doesn't seek world domination? AHEM?!

It's the *Tango* guys who made this for the tango theme, not "Human" specifically! Furthermore, if those icons were packaged in tango-icon-theme instead of tangerine, tangerine & human would STILL have those icons *anyway* because they INHERIT tango!

[VF (vfiend)]

Perhaps he means the new tango gtk stock icons will be going into gtk itself and won't have to be in tango

[Andreas Nilsson (andreasn)]

They are in gtk+ trunk now!
http://svn.gnome.org/viewcvs/gtk%2B/trunk/gtk/stock-icons/

[Jeff Fortin Tam (kiddo)]

Well, GTK looks pretty now.