split amount opposite sign don't work when using + button

[Noel Utter]

OS: Windows 10
HomeBank version: 5.5.5 (bug already noticed in previous versions)

When I add a positive amount in the split for a negative amount transaction, the sign is no kept and goes negative.

I have to edit the split to change the sign.

Example:
- Create a transaction with an amount of -1000€
- Open transaction splits
- Enter an amount of 200€ (positive)
- Click on "+" button to add the split line
-> The split line is created with an amount of -200€ (negative) and the unassigned amount goes to -800€
Turnaround:
- Edit the line using the pencil button
- Change the sign
- Click on the check button
-> The split line is corrected with the amount well signed, and the unassigned amount goes to -1200€

[Noel Utter (noelutter)]

See printscreens in attached document.

[Maxime DOYEN (mdoyen)]

http://homebank.free.fr/help/dlg-spli.html

Amount the amount of the split line
to force a positive amount enter +xxx
to force a negative amount enter -xxx

[Noel Utter (noelutter)]

Sorry, but if the total amount is negative, it isn't OK: Impossible to add a positive split line even with adding the "+" sign (without using the turnaround).

If the total amount is positive, adding a negative split line is OK.

[letoloke (molina26ricardo)]

i believe mdoyen is correct here, i saw the screenshots and don't see any problems, the way its behalf now it's ok, just add the minus sing and that's it

There are situations where i have an income that contains a commission on it, this kind of transaction split can help since it has an income and expense kind of in the same transaction, however i stop using split transactions since i can't export them correctly

[TG (tiagograca)]

Related to https://bugs.launchpad.net/homebank/+bug/1965803

Even if I use the + sign in front, HomeBank doesn't seem to keep it : https://bugs.launchpad.net/homebank/+bug/1965803/+attachment/5581311/+files/tRg5lXYeRu.gif

Anyone able to reproduce?

[Maxime DOYEN (mdoyen)]

ok, its when you click on + button
when you enter on after inpit amount +200 it works

simply miss a gtk_spin_button_update somewhere

[Noel Utter (noelutter)]

Hello Maxime, sorry but this bug is still present in 5.5.6

See attached document

[William (william-n-havard)]

I can confirm the bug is still here. It also happens when trying to add a negative number to a positive amount. See attached screenshots.