PHP extension 'MapScript' only runs in Apache DSO

[SteveM@SML]

Binary package hint: php5-mapscript

The PHP5 MapScript extension (from the UMN MapServer project) does not work when PHP5 is running in either CGI/FCGI or CLI modes. For example, when trying to use the MapScript extension in a PHP5 script run from the command line, the following error message is emitted:

"This build of mapscript can't be load as a 'cli' module for stability reason, but only with php as an apache DSO."

I have examined the package source, and I have isolated the cause of this bug. There is a specific patch in the Debian build source for package 'php5-mapscript' that inserts a check in the startup code for the PHP/MapScript extension. The inserted code checks the sapi_module name, and if it is 'cli', 'cgi', or 'cgi-fcgi', the extension emits the above error message, and exits.

Specifically, the patch is: mapserver-${version}/debian/patches/20_php_build.dpatch
(As I write this, ${version} == "4.10.2".)

Whatever the reason for forbidding the use of the PHP/MapScript extension in CGI/FCGI or CLI modes, I believe that it is no longer valid. In fact, the MapServer documentation recommends running PHP/MapScript in CGI mode, in preference to DSO.

See: http://mapserver.gis.umn.edu/docs/howto/phpmapscript-install
Specifically, this FAQ appears there:
Q: Does PHP/Mapscript have to be setup as a CGI? If so, why?
A: Yes, please see the [link]PHP/Mapscript CGI page[/link] in the Mapserver Wiki for details.

I feel that the simplest and best remedy for this bug is to remove the above patch ('20_php_build.dpatch') from the package build source. Furthermore, the package comments or notes ideally should mention that PHP/MapScript is recommended to be run in PHP as CGI, and possibly even warn users that there could be instability issues when run in DSO mode.

[SteveM@SML (stevem-spatialmapping-com)]

For convenience, I have attached a copy of '20_php_build.dpatch' from the 'debian/patches' directory of the 'mapserver' package. As mentioned in my bug report, I am requesting that this patch be removed from the package source.

[SteveM@SML (stevem-spatialmapping-com)]

I have submitted this bug upstream to the Debian MapServer package maintainers.

Here's a link to the Debian bug report page:
http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=447814

[SteveM@SML (stevem-spatialmapping-com)]

Good news. It appears this bug has been fixed upstream by the Debian MapServer package maintainers, at version 5.0.0-3 .
Full details are in the Debian bug page (see link in my previous comment).

[SteveM@SML (stevem-spatialmapping-com)]

Fixed upstream in Debian, at version 5.0.0-3.

[Artur Rona (ari-tczew)]

 mapserver (5.0.0-3) unstable; urgency=low

   * debian/php5-mapscript.postinst: fixed a typo. (Closes: #446985)
   * debian/patches/20_php_build.dpatch: removed. (Closes: #447814)
   * debian/po/gl.po: added. (Closes: #447939)
   * debian/po/fr.po: added. (Closes: #448821)

 -- Fabio Tranchitella <email address hidden> Thu, 08 Nov 2007 15:13:37 +0100